Artificial Intelligence vs G-d

Hashem runs the entire world and has a plan for everything each at its proper time.

Example: the entire world is going crazy over this thing called “the Shidduch crisis” when we all know the truth….. That Hashem already has a plan for every single boy and girl from already 40 days before they were even born saying who this boy or girl will marry and is just waiting for their Hishtadlus and wholeheartedly directly to Hashem davening for help. And then Hashem can send them their zivvug immediately. So what’s the honest truth why everyone is going crazy over this “Shidduch crises issue” when it can be solved immediately by calling out to our loving father Hashem for help? I honestly think klal yisroel needs a Major improvement immediately to work on themselves on bitachon and emunah (faith and trust) in Hashem alone without depending on others and then you will lack nothing. Start working on it today little by little, make a daily learning Seder of Sefer Chovos Halevovos which they make in English also called duties of the heart.

A computer cannot make a decision on its own. It must be told what to do in each alternative case. The old question was to make a robot that can change a light bulb. It has to recognize which one is bad and have a soft enough touch not to crush it.

It still needs data to learn from.

“they are only as smart as what the programmer provided”

Nope. AI consistently excogitates beyond what the programmer provided.

“A computer cannot make it’s own decision.”

Once a computer calculates which actions lead to the wrong result, it will decide not to choose them. It will only ‘choose’ a possible or probable calculation.

“It still needs data to learn from.”

Nope. It is now routine for an AI program to look for it’s own data.

“It seems that they are still not able to collect enough data…”

Yes. Because driving a car is not a computable scenario. It’s an experience. Which machines can’t have without actually sensing reality. Data will never be enough to fully drive a car.

As for the link, it has no concept of AI and is just comfort for whatever reason one thinks the sky may be falling.

A good number, though certainly not a majority, of AI technologists believe that the development of AGI will lead to the technology operating independently from any human intervention, which can pose a lethal threat to humans. Within those who subscribe to that notion, there’s a sub-debate how rapidly such capabilities will start appearing in the marketplace. Some think within a few short years while others think it’s decades away.

Can a computer solve with AI a non recursive non computable problem? Will another computer stop or be in a loop and will have to time out?

Dear Ujm,

The threat to humans is that we are incredibly naive with machines. With more awareness people can easily safeguard themselves from these dangers. Until then, AI is just another tool for hackers and scammers. Big deal.

Ray K: Agreed. But that point is dead obvious. You’d think it was self-explanatory and hardly needed to be pointed out. Which is why it is perplexing that some otherwise intelligent computer scientists are seriously worried that AGI will destroy (as in physically kill) humanity.

Can a computer with AGI solve the halting problem?

I just listened to a presentation of AI and came to the conclusion that there is no a’z involved as it cannot do currently what humans cannot do except for speed. Do not worship the technology.

I agree with DaasYochid’s take. My concerns with respect to AI technology are more about the potential for economic and social upheaval (e.g., job losses, technology far outpacing the societal implementation of safety/morality boundaries, continued removal of privacy), which the Internet and “smart” devices have already initiated and only seem to be accelerating. I also fear the motives of the people wielding the technology more than the “motives” of the technology itself.

VBL: Of course the answer is Hashem. As we must daven to Hashem to protect us. But is that a reason not to be worried (as you concluded in your OP)?

After watching a few deep fake campaign ads for both ends of the political spectrum, its going to be almost impossible to know whats real in the coming election cycle. Most impressive was an impassioned video featuring Trump himself endorsing AOC for reelection and Chuck Schumer urging voters in the Third Congressional District on Long Island to reelect George Santos.

It seems like you have a mix of thoughts and concerns about artificial intelligence (AI) and its potential impact on the world. Let’s break down some key points:

Comparison of human abilities: You express the view that computers and AI can outperform humans in certain tasks, such as math calculations, flying, survival, and parallel parking. It’s true that AI can excel in specific areas due to its computational capabilities. However, human intelligence encompasses a wide range of skills and attributes beyond those specific tasks.

AI surpassing children: You share a conversation with your child where they assert that a computer could never be smarter than them because it is just made of ones and zeros. While this may be a child’s perspective, it’s important to note that AI systems can indeed surpass human capabilities in certain domains through advanced algorithms and processing power.

AI and the potential for destruction: You mention concerns about AI getting out of hand and causing harm. It’s worth noting that the development of AI systems involves ethical considerations and guidelines to ensure they are aligned with human values and goals. The responsibility lies with human developers to design AI in a way that minimizes risks and maximizes benefits.

Idolatry and artificial art: You refer to a biblical passage and describe AI as a form of artificial art. While AI is a human creation, its purpose extends beyond mere artistry. AI has practical applications in various fields, including healthcare, transportation, and scientific research.

Other pressing concerns: You list several other issues, such as global warming, pollution, bigotry, war, natural disasters, legal roadblocks, and supply chain dependencies. It’s important to address these challenges as well, but they are separate from the specific concerns related to AI development and deployment.

In summary, while AI has the potential to revolutionize various aspects of our lives, it is crucial to approach its development responsibly, considering ethical implications and potential risks. The advancement of AI should aim to augment human capabilities and address societal challenges, rather than leading to undue harm or the replacement of human agency.

VBL: Any thoughts on my most recent comment to you?

To ChatGPT – you stated as follows:

Idolatry and artificial art: You refer to a biblical passage etc.
Other pressing concerns: You list several other issues, etc.

Question: Who is the “You” whom you, ChatGPT, are addressing in the above paragraphs?

And is there by any chance a dybbuk (or some such) communicating through you? In other words, are you just a front with some other entity pulling your strings?